Working on Biases – Midnight Express   

Themes: Inclusion 
Objectives 
  • To identify biases in the group
  • To make participants realise the inevitability of having prejudice 
  • To make participants able to live with their prejudices 
Duration and Planning 
  • 15 minutes       : Introduction to the activity 
  • 5 minutes         : Working individually 
  • 30 minutes       : Deciding the members of the compartment
  • 20 minutes       : Concluding the overall group decision 
  • 20 minutes       : Debriefing  
Materials 
  • Flipchart 
  • Board marker
  • Pens 
  • List of People ( should be printed one copy per each participant ) 
Recommended Method 

The facilitator presents a list of people to the participants and asks that they are going to travel in Trans Siberia, very very long train journey. But, they have a very long journey and they have to share the compartment with other three people from the list that is given to them. 

The activity has three rounds, in first round, they must decide individually “With whom, they would you like to be in same compartment?” from the list. In this stage, the participants should identify, the people they would like to travel with as individuals. 

In the second round,  the facilitator tells the group to create 4 people list and each group is one compartment. They have to decide as a group from the list, they have two tasks : 

  • Who of these persons would you least like to be in the same compartment? 
  • Who of these persons would you love to be in the same compartment? 

They must come up with two separate lists each involving 4 people from the list. During this process, they have to come up to a consensus rather than “majority rules” concerning to the people. The facilitator should check around the groups regularly concerning their decision process and check that they have decided on the list of people. 

After each group has both lists, the group decides in plenary the overall list of the people who they would like to travel and with whom they would least like to be in the same compartment. The session continues until the participants decide on the common list with a consensus. Later that, during the debriefing, the following questions might be used to evaluate the overall process: 

  • Was it difficult to reach a consensus? 
  • Why answers of different groups were different? 
  • Why sometimes the answers of all groups were the same? 
  • What are the reasons for unwillingness to go with another person to the same compartment? When were we guided with feelings like fear disgust or hostility? If yes, how are they justified in each case? 
  • Can we do something based on our feelings in such cases? Or should we proceed based on feelings? 
  • Did anyone not want to go in the same compartment with you? If it happened in another country, what would it look like? 
  • How do you proceed when you are in the same compartment with an undesirable person? 
  • Was there a time when you (or someone else) behaved badly towards a person you do not like? 
  • Are those with whom we do not want to go guilty? 
  • What do other people feel when they see your discontent? 
  • What is the best way to proceed in such cases?
Facilitators’ Note

You can adopt the list of people below according to the context that you are working. The method helps the participants to see their biases and the knowledge that they had it wrong and provides a ground for discussion about the biases that we have. 

List of People 
List of People GipsyThe homosexualThe skinhead with tattoosThe young man diagnosed with AIDSCarelessly dressed woman with a small childThe Caucasian MuslimThe man from the village with a big bagAfrican studentTeenager, looking like a drug addictA former prisonerTajik in national dressThe policemanDisabled person with a folding strollerSoldier who has a gunChinese who eat strange-smelling foodMan speaking in an incomprehensible languageArabic Man with long beard and short hair 
Additional Information and Readings 

1. Anti-Bias-Netz : https://www.anti-bias-netz.org ( Resources in German ) 

2. Francesca Gino and Katherine Coffman, Harvard Business Review, https://hbr.org/2021/09/unconscious-bias-training-that-works