Photo Challenge

Objectives
  • To make participants practice the skills that they have gained 
  • To make participants initiate narration 
  • To make participants understand the power of photography 
  • To make participants understand the differentiation of perception i.e. reflexivity of art  
  • To create a common understanding to develop the field trip  
Duration and Planning

5 minutes : Introducing Photo Challenge 

45 minutes : Practice Session 

25 minutes : Presentation of the stories  

15 minutes : Debriefing 

Materials 
  • Projector 
  • Use the slide dedicated to this session 
  • Papers 
  • Pen 
  • Post-it 
  • USB/SD Card to transfer photos 
  • Flipchart for narration or composition development 
  • Boardmarkers 
Recommended Method

The facilitator explains the next stage of the activity “Photo Challenge”. During the photo challenge, you divide participants into the 4 separate groups of 5 people. The participants are asked to take 3 photos in 45 minutes on the following issues by creating composition by themselves. In this sense, they must think a composition as a group and go through the all knowledge that they have learnt previously and create a composition by themselves. Each group will have one topic. The facilitator can give them randomly or ask participants to choose by themselves. 

Themes ( it can be changed by the facilitator according to the group wishes/interests ) : 

  1. Inclusion
  2. Violence
  3. Peace 
  4. Discrimination 

They are asked to create an imaginary story by using the photos and narrating the photos. Each group should come up with a story with the narration of photos from their point of view. After 45 minutes, the participants come back to the group.

The facilitator provides the rules of the presentation for the participants :  

  • First without the narrations of the group, solely the photos should be shown. 
  • The commentary from the other groups should be taken. 
  • Then the narrations developed from the group’s perspective should be presented. 
  • Without continuing the discussion, the next group should continue in the same order. 

You can ask participants to show with the narrations in one round if the time does not allow you to do so, though, by introducing these rules, you will be able to make participants to review the difference between “How others see?” rather than “What do they have tried to mean?”. Thus, by doing so, you have an opportunity to go deeper in the debriefing and evaluation to tackle with the issues that might happen after the developing of stories tomorrow. 

After the discussion is over facilitator ask participants to choose as a group 1 photo in 5 minutes to analyse technically according to the knowledge that they have gained during “Learning about Photography” session. After the analysis of the pictures from technical perspective such as “aperture”, “shutter speed”, “iso”, “framing”, “angle”, etc. The facilitator continues with the debriefing and evaluation. 

Debriefing and Evaluation

During the debriefing and evaluation of this session, you can use the following guiding questions to initiate the discussion : 

  • How did you feel about creating the composition? What is hard or easy? 
  • Were your narration and the understanding of the others similar? 
  • If not, why do you think it was different?
  • Do you think that the images that we see perceives different according to our identities? 
  • If you want to go back and create the story again, what would you make different? 
  • How was the overall process of developing the composition, scene and narratives? 
Tips for Facilitators 

During the presentation of the stories, as facilitator try to be partial and do not provide your opinions about the photos and narrations rather than leading the group. The ideas might differentiate, and some participants’ can get offended or consider that their work is not enough to be presented which might lead them to be demotivated for the next day. Thus, it is highly important that you keep the balance in the group and simply say “There is no right or wrong!” to keep participants engaged fully for the next day. 

You can as well provide information on the reflexivity of the photography to make participants understand the reasoning in a deepened may of this workshop right before the field trip. For that you can check the readings below. 

This activity is a sneak peak of the overall tomorrow and thus, the participants should be motivated and kept eager to continue with the field trip. 

Additional Information and Readings 

The slide of the session can be downloaded from here : https://links.verdesur.org/slides-1st-day-photography

Bertram, G. W. (2019). Art as human practice: An Aesthetics. Bloomsbury Publishing.

Nassim Daghighian - Reflexivity in Contemporary Photography  | http://phototheoria.ch/up/reflexivity.pdf

Susan Sonntag – On Photography | https://writing.upenn.edu/library/Sontag-Susan-Photography.pdf

Steven West – PodCast ( Susan Sontag - Do you speak the language of pictures and videos? )|  https://www.philosophizethis.org/transcript/episode-177-transcript