Monitoring and Evaluation Report of the Training of Trainers Activity

The monitoring and evaluation report is developed in the initial phase of the project as explained in the previous section. In this section, the achievements of the final training activity and the involvement of participants to the evaluation process is discussed and explained in detailed. 

The following questions were used to develop the basis of the monitoring and the evaluation strategy implemented within the Training of Trainers Activity: 

  • In line with the objectives of the training, to objectives, to what extent and in what way did the participants' knowledge, attitudes and skills regarding their inclusive photography is changed? 
  • Were there any knowledge, attitudes and skills that did not change in the planned direction? 
  • To what extent were the participants' expectations about the program reached? 
  • What were the methods used during the training process and what kind of learning took place during the training process? 
  • Have the participants reached the competencies to develop projects in their fields? 

During the process, the project coordinator from Spain was involved in the development of the training program and took the role of the overall monitoring and evaluation process of the program and provided information about the implementation of the monitoring and evaluation throughout the implementation of the training activities. 

The learning objectives were planned as : 

  • To make the youth workers aware about the issues of inclusion and usage of photography 
  • To create a network of youth workers who will engage in the implementation of local photo walk activities 
  • To make young people to familiar with the local photo walk and visual storytelling methodologies 
  • To plan the local activities as a follow-up structure and the further steps of the project  

For the implementation of the evaluation, the following form is used :https://forms.office.com/e/hEjtCg9PyX

The evaluation process as explained above under “Monitoring And Evaluation For Inclusive Photography Activities” was implemented one-stage at the end of the training by using the same methodology in each activity implemented within the project. 

To understand the satisfaction rate of the participants from the training activity, the Likert Scale evaluation methodology have been used. 

Demographics of Participants 

The median age of participants was 25,26 years old. The oldest participants was 61 years old and the youngest participant was 18 years old. The trainer team was consisted of 3 youth workers aged between 34-46 years old. The participants were consisted of 11 female and 5 male. Each country has involved 5 participants including trainers from the staff of the organizations who are voluntarily and professionally involved. 

Moreover, the activities were implemented jointly with the involvement of the staff of the organizations to engage the staff on the implementation of the activities as well as in the later stages of the project. The evaluation was made under three segments: Competences, Open-ended feedback questions and Overall Satisfaction (NPS Score). 

Competencies 

The participants were requested to answer, following statements by reflecting their experience before and after the training activity. They were asked to choose the most suitable option from 5 Likert Scale. 

Statements
ST1 I have a knowledge about inclusion and its relation with human rights. 
ST2I am aware about the difference of perception and how we interpret images according to our biases. 
ST3I am aware about the biases that I have and I can deal with them. 
ST4I know how to approach people with different backgrounds during making photos. 
ST5I am aware about the issues in my own community and how it impacts on my perspective. 
ST6I can implement non-formal education activities. 
ST7I can develop material for the implementation of the local activities within the project. 
ST8I can develop photography sessions concerning to usage of camera or programs related to photo-editing.
ST9I am able to implement and organize local photography activities with the young people with fewer opportunities. 
ST10I can develop visual stories with using photography and text. 
ST11I know the implications of photography in the lives of the other people. 
ST12I can implement activities with the people from other countries in international context. 
ST13I am aware about the cultural differences. 
ST14I can develop educational programs for young people with the theme of photography and inclusion. 
ST15I believe I can implement workshop activity with the young people in my community by using the tools that I have gained here. 

Each statement is related to the one competence area concerning to the knowledge, skills and the attitudes of the participants to be planned to developed within the training. In the first section of the analysis of the competences, we have asked participants to evaluate themselves before the trainings concerning to the Statements Above. The result of this evaluation was as in the graphic below. 

According to the each statement area, change can be seen related to the knowledge, attitude and skills concerning to the social rights of young people and the human rights of young people. In that sense, the change between the competence areas demonstrate that the training activity reach out its goals in terms of developing competences among the young people concerning inclusion and usage of photography through the inclusion. 

Questions related to satisfaction rate of the participants from the training activities 


Choose your satisfaction level from the training 1 ( Not at all ) - 10 ( Totally ) 

When we have asked the participants to define their satisfaction level from the training from 1-10 according to the Likert Scale from 1-10, the satisfaction rate indicated as 7.74 from the Likert scale of 10 with majority of the participants voting as 10 concerning to the overall content of the training activities as well as the logistics. It shows that the participants enjoyed and were satisfied from the overall content and logistics. 

Choose your satisfaction level from the logistical preparation of the training 1 ( Not at all ) - 10 ( Totally ) 

When we have asked participants about the logistical preparation of the training and their satisfaction level, the overall valuation was 7.79 from the Likert scale of 10. It shows that it requires an improvement concerning to the logistics. 


Choose your satisfaction level from the field trip within the training 1 ( Not at all ) - 10 ( Totally ) 

When we have asked participants about the field trip, the overall valuation was 8.42 from the Likert Scale of 10. Even though, the language barriers exists for the implementation of the field trip activities, the responses of the participants indicates that, they have highly satisfied from the implementation of the field trip activity within the training. 


Choose your satisfaction level from the content of the training( Not at all ) - 10 ( Totally ) 

When we have asked participants about the overall content of the training and workshops, the valuation was 8.1 from the Likert Scale of 10. It shows that the sessions developed addressed the needs of the participants concerning to the implementation of the local activities in relation with the content of the training. 

Open-ended feedback questions 

Participants were asked “Which session or which part of training was most valuable to you? Why?”, their responses showed that the participants gained most from the field trip activity as well as the photography editing according to the comment of the participants. Even though, there was a translation between the participants, it was indicated by one of the participants that the translation was not enough as a downside of the field trip activity. 

“Taking pictures of the people in the village, because we had a chance to see what their daily life is like.” – 20_F 

“The one about learning how to use digital tools for the editing part of the photo session, because it was the topic I was kinda unaware about“ – 21_F

“I loved the field trip because it was more practical even if it could have been more interactive with people through Turkish-English translation and explanation about activities and environment.” – 28_F 

In the second question, the participants were asked to identify the missing points of the training by answering the question “Was there anything you found missing in the training? What if, how would it be better if we did it?”. Majority of the participants indicated that they haven’t found nothing was missing. Though, the following comments gave us a room for improvement for the training content in relation with the editing of the photos which we have thought upon briefly during the implementation of the training due to constraints of the time and not focusing on the aesthetics rather than the development of the images. 

“I found the part about photo editing limited and more explanation should have been given.” – 18_M

To understand the follow-up plans of the participants, we have asked “What is your plan to do with the knowledge/tools and approaches that you have learnt here after the training?” to the participants. It gave us an overview of the overall plans of the participants according to the following comments, the participants plan to use the knowledge in their local communities to continue after the implementation of the trainings. 


“Implement them in my daily life and try to share them with the people of same interest (photography) and the wider local community (inclusion) “- 21_F

“I want to use those skills for projects in anthropological and cooperation projects” – 18_M

“Make a workshop in my hometown” – 22_F

We have asked participants to answer their perceptions concerning to the organisations involved in the project to understand the aspects of support from the organizations as hosting and sending due to the long-term partnership to solve the issues that might raise in advance by receiving the feedbacks from the participants. To understand that we have asked participants “Do you have any comments on our organisation and your organisations? What would you want us to change?”. Their answers demonstrated that the participants were satisfied from the conduct of the organizations as majority of the feedbacks were positive. 

The participants answered “Do you have any comments on the logistical issues? What would you want us to change?”. The answers demonstrates that, the logistics in general was considered positive by the participants according to the comments except than the remoteness of the hotel which was arranged. 

During the training we have developed the future plans and to understand, the participants plans and their wishes from us as organizers and the consortium partners, the following question was asked “ What would do you expect from us after the training?”, the answers demonstrated that, the participants willing to engage on the activities of the project later on and involve more in the organizations that engaged in the project by implementing activities focused on the photography and community development.  

The overall evaluation of the training activity showed us that the participants had gained competences related to photography and inclusion and qualified participants concerning to the implementation of the local activities as it demonstrated in the qualitative and quantitative evaluation outputs.  In addition to that, the training activity motivated participants to engage in the further education activities within their organizations and make them involve more in the implementation of this project as well as the other projects that the organizations have been carrying on. The results of the research activities that have been carried as a result of involvement to the local photowalk activities which helped us to reach around 325 young people in the implementation period from Spain, Turkey, Italy and Serbia. Lastly, the training of trainers activity helped us to create a network of youth workers experienced on usage of photography and inclusion techniques in the local communities.