Monitoring and Evaluation for Inclusive Photography Activities

The main purpose of the monitoring and evaluation process were to assess the effectiveness of “Inclusive Photography for Youth – Tools for Youth Workers to Engage Young People with Photography” project in terms of its aims and objectives. The evaluation process is developed to provide relevant information to improve the follow-up processes of the project as well as to serve as a guide to the other organizations and give information about the lessons learnt, the challenges and the obstacles faced during the implementation of the activities.  During the monitoring and evaluation, both quantitative and qualitative research methods were used and evaluation forms for each training program, qualitative and quantitative instruments can be found in the related activities’ evaluation sections as online forms. To reduce the paper for the evaluation process, we have developed the overall evaluation methodology as an online format. 

The main objective of the project is develop tools for youth workers to engage with excluded and marginalised young people by using documentary photography to promote the active citizenship and inclusion of young people while making young people to document and raise their voices towards to issues that they see in their own communities. For reaching out this aim, the following objectives were set out during the project cycle : 

- To provide tools for youth workers to make them able for engaging young people to raise their voices through photography tools such as visual story telling, photovoice methodology

- To document the issues of the young people in participating countries from the perspective of young people through photowalk workshops

- To increase the skills of young people to become changemakers in their own communities through the usage of photovoice, photography and documentary photography techniques

- To create an awareness about the issues of young people by providing space for young people in the participating countries as well as through implementation of exhibitions

Therefore, to reach these objectives 27 main activities planned to be implemented (16 Photo Walk Trainings, 4 Visual Storytelling Workshops, 1 Training of Trainers and 1 Training for Young People, 4 National Exhibitions and 1 International Exhibition ) with the involvement of 320 young people from 4 different countries ( Spain, Italy, Serbia, Turkey ). Here therein, the evaluation methodology is laid out in the first stage of this handbook and evaluation report will be published in the end of the project and attached to this form. 

During the development of this handbook, only Training of Trainers activity was implemented with the involvement of 20 youth workers from Spain, Italy, Serbia and Turkey in Giresun, Turkey between 19-25 September 2023. During the implementation of this training course, there has been no difficulties with the participants and the methodology and output of the monitoring and evaluation report can be found in the end of this book. 

This monitoring and evaluation strategy is developed to understand that the above mentioned activities contributed to the general aim and helped young people and youth workers to develop attitudes, skills and knowledge i.e. competences during the implementation of the activities. With the planning process of this evaluation strategy, we planned to answer the following questions in the end of the project : 

  • Did Training of Trainers activity contributed to the professional development of youth workers? 
  • Did Photo Walk Trainings provided participants with relevant skills, knowledge and attitudes aimed at the project? 
  • Did Visual Storytelling workshops prepared participants to engage exhibition process fully? 
  • Did Exhibitions create an impact on the overall community? 
  • What was the overall satisfaction of the participants of each activity? 

The development of the monitoring and evaluation strategy was done with the involvement of the staff of the partner organizations and the evaluation forms are developed in one stage rather than pre- and post-form stages. The reasoning behind this way of development of the strategy has been that the participants would not over-evaluate themselves prior to participating in the activity as well as gathering the results that are unrealistic.

This issue is called as response-bias[1] in social science. Response bias “is a general term for a wide range of tendencies for participants to respond inaccurately or falsely to questions. These biases are prevalent in research involving participant self-report, such as structured interviews or surveys. Response biases can have a large impact on the validity of questionnaires or surveys”.Therefore, to overcome this issue, we have internalised the following monitoring and evaluation strategy rather than the exhibition due to huge number of viewers and not every viewers possibility to fill out a longer survey as well as willingness. 

Therefore, the evaluation process is done one-stage, at the end of the training/workshop : 

  • Before the training/workshop : by asking participants to evaluate themselves after the training concerning to their prior knowledge before participation to activity. 
  • After the training/workshop : by asking participants to evaluate themselves after the training concerning to their current knowledge/skill-set/attitudes. 

In addition to that, for the national activities, we have developed a multi-lingual form translated by the consortium members to gather the overall answers in one place to be able to develop both country-specific and comparative evaluation of the activities took place in each country. 

Training of Trainers for Youth Workers Evaluation Form    : https://forms.office.com/e/hEjtCg9PyX

National Photo Walk Workshops Evaluation Form              : https://forms.office.com/e/SazhfdeP1r

National Visual Storytelling Workshops Evaluation Form   : https://forms.office.com/e/mYLuPqSjss

In exhibition, the evaluation is planned to be implemented with feedback forms (online and paper format), to gather the viewers overall satisfaction and expression from the evaluation. That can be seen in the exhibition feedback form ( Exhibition Feedback Form : https://links.verdesur.org/Exhibition-Feedback-Form-EN ). Each organisation will develop a report concerning to exhibition consisting the feedbacks from the general audience.

Methodology and Tools 

While developing monitoring and evaluation methods and tools, it was believed that the practices carried out for this purpose should be positioned as a part of the training program process, not as an end-of-project study. In line with this belief, methods and tools were developed within the knowledge of the project and training teams, in parallel with the training program development process, before the project implementation phase began. 

Overall process of the evaluation strategy is developed in four stages due to the nature of the project. The scheme of the monitoring and evaluation strategy and development of the plan can be seen below. 

The above methodology will help us as consortium to follow-up the outcomes of every stage and to tackle with the challenges and obstacles of the possible activities. In that way, we as partners will be able to follow-up each other’s work throughout the online tools as well as document every step to have a full fetched evaluation process. 

The tools identified for the implementation of the monitoring and evaluation strategies are : 

  • Application forms to gather the expectations 
  • Post-Test forms to evaluate the overall satisfaction and change upon the participants
  • Quantitative indicators to understand the achievement of the activity 
  • Feedback forms to receive detailed impression from the viewers of national exhibitions 
  • Daily Evaluations to adjust the content to increase the participants’ needs 
  • Verbal Evaluation to make participants’ discuss and provide direct feedback not only to the team but to the participants’ as well 
  • Partner Evaluations to evaluate to overall consortium 
  • Quantitative Indicators for overall project to understand the achievement of the project 
  • Lessons’ Learnt are to be a guiding principle for the partners for next projects
  • Follow-up measures to provide pathway to return to development of new projects. 

These tools have been used and the following monitoring and evaluation reports were developed to learn about the achievements and the lessons learnt of each activity implemented within the project.

These reports can be achieved from here.  


[1] Furnham, Adrian (1986). "Response bias, social desirability and dissimulation". Personality and Individual Differences. 7 (3): 385–400. doi:10.1016/0191-8869(86)90014-0.