l'art pour l'art ou l'art pour l'homme

Themes: Photography & Inclusion  
Objectives 
  • To understand reflexivity of art particularly in photography 
  • To examine whether art is for its own stake or it serves a broader purpose 
  • To brainstorm the usage of art and photography in daily life 
  • To make participants understanding aesthetics and conveying social messages 
Duration and Planning 
  • 15 minutes       : Introduction to Reflexivity in art  
  • 30 minutes       : Historical Context of Reflexivity in Art   
  • 30 minutes       : Aesthetics vs. Social Change  
  • 15 minutes       : Discussion in plenary 
Materials 
  • Flipchart 
  • Board marker
  • Pens 
  • Camera 
  • Internet 
Recommended Method 

The facilitator puts in the sentence in a flipchart as “L’art por l’art ou L’art pour L’homme” and ask participants that they know the meaning of the sentence to initiate a discussion. During this process, the facilitator explains the historical aspects of the terminologies as “Art for art’s sake” which focuses on beauty, form and the vision of the art while “Art for human’s sake” puts the artistic products beyond itself engaging the art with social political or ethical issues. 

In that sense, the facilitator asks participants to define the aesthetic values of photography and using the photography to promote the social change and asks participants the following guiding questions to facilitate the discussion on the reflexivity of art: 

  • Should photography serve a purpose beyond aesthetic value?
  • Can photography be both reflexive and socially engaged?
  • Photography is for human’s sake or art’s sake? 

After the discussions, the facilitator provides information on the usage of photography by focusing on aesthetics by using the examples from the well-known photographers such as Edward Weston, Ansel Adams to show the examples of the “Art for Art’s sake approach on photography”. 

The facilitator can use other resources focusing on the aesthetics approach on photography as well though, Edward Weston and Ansel Adams approach provides a clear-cut definition when it comes to the reflexivity of art and the usage of photography solely from aesthetics point of view. The main purpose of this activity is to show the participants the change on the photographs from only aesthetic view to a social change tool.

In the second round of the session, the facilitator asks participants to define several examples from their knowledge concerning to the photographers whose work serves for a social or political purpose. After the examples, the facilitator provides the examples from the works of Dorothea Lange and Sebastiao Salgado who has been pioneers of the documentary photography. During this process, the facilitator asks participants what they see in the works and what they have developed and their works on the documentary photography.  

Afterwards, the participants are divided to groups of 3 to develop a concept photography that represents the idea of “Art for Art’s Sake” by solely focusing on the aesthetics and “Art for Humanity’s Sake” by conveying a social message or reflecting a human issue. As a group, they have to create at least 2 photos differentiating a both, so that the participants work together as a team of 3 to develop in both pictures for next 30 minutes. 

After the finalisation of the group works, the participants present their photos and choice behind the development of each photo concerning the usage of photography solely for aesthetics and for social change. Each group present their work for 2 minutes and the overall group provides feedback after overall presentations are completed. According to the results from the participants, the facilitator starts the discussion by using the following guiding questions : 

  • Have you ever thought about the differences between the aesthetics and humanity? 
  • Did you face difficulties while developing the images focusing on aesthetics or social change? 
  • How did you decide on the image that you want to propose for both aspects? 
  • Do you think while promoting social change, the aesthetics play a role or not? 

The facilitator closes the session by informing participants on the general aspects of the photography concerning the reflexivity and the aesthetics. 

Facilitators’ Note
The facilitator should make him/herself familiarize with the reflexivity in art and photography by using “Additional Information and Readings” section. In addition to that, the facilitator can choose well-known national photographers to make the participants aware about the differences of aesthetics and the documentary photography in case that the training is implemented in national context.  
Additional Information and Readings 

Photos of Edward Weston : https://www.holdenluntz.com/artists/edward-weston/

Photos of Ansel Adams : https://www.anseladams.com

Photos of Dorothea Lange : 

https://www.icp.org/browse/archive/constituents/dorothea-lange?all/all/all/all/0

Photos of Sebastião Salgado : 

https://www.icp.org/browse/archive/constituents/sebastião-salgado?all/all/all/all/0

Bertram, G. W. (2019). Art as human practice: An Aesthetics. Bloomsbury Publishing.

Nassim Daghighian - Reflexivity in Contemporary Photography  | http://phototheoria.ch/up/reflexivity.pdf