Introduction to Inclusive Photography
Objectives
- To get to know each other
- To create group dynamic
- To take expectations of the participants
- To present the workshop schedule to the participants
- To inform the participants about the Photovoice method
Duration and Planning
10 minutes : Introduction of the project & workshop schedule & Questions and Answers
20 minutes : “Say me why you are here?”
10 minutes : Rules of Engagement
30 minutes : Introduction of Photo Voice Method and Inclusive Photography
20 minutes : Diving into Photo Voice Method
Recommended Method
The Opening Session begins with facilitators “Welcome” speech. The facilitator presents the project and the project and the activities that are taking place within the overall project. Then presents the workshop schedule alike above and answers the questions.
“Say me why you are here” : The participants are asked to get up from the chairs and form a circle. Than each participant, says their name and their reasons and expectations from the workshop. To make the activity interactive, the participants should form their sentences concerning their reasons with starting the ending letter of the previous person’s sentence. Clockwise, the participant will continue with their name by creating a sentence by finishing the end of the other. The activity is ends when the circle comes to first person.
Example of the sequence :
First Person : My name is Mark, I am here because I want to learn about inclusive photography.
The next person : Your name was Mark, I am called as Juan. I am here to get to know more people. I fear to be bad photographer.
The third person : Rare names are different, and I hope the people has interest. I am Inmaculada. I expect to learn about photography techniques.
The fourth person : Same here. I am Jane…..
In this way, the participants will be able to call each other with their names and their expectations, fears and reasons to be in the workshop will be gathered in an interactive, engaging and fun way. The participants should be told to say not more than 4 sentences to keep the time according to the method schedule.
Rules of Engagement
The facilitator writes “Rules of Engagement” in a flipchart paper and explains that there are rules of engagement in different types of sport while engaging with the competitor within the sport to keep the order. However, these rules come from top-down.
But within this training activity, the participants will be asked to define the rules by themselves that should be respected overall training activity. They are given 5 minutes to think and after with the discussion at least 10 rules are defined and agreed as a group to follow-up.
One of these rules will be for sure “Being on time”, “Respecting each other” etc., but the facilitators should dig deeper to give participants “confidentiality” and “not existence of wrong answers”.
Introduction of Photo Voice Method and Inclusive Photography
The participants are presented several photos and asked to choose 1 photo among the 20 pictures that are presented to them. In the resource pack, you can find 20 photos that are randomly chosen from the pictures of the activities or taken by the team of handbook. You can as well print the pictures or show them in a show case in projector by giving them numbers so that the participants can chose the number.
- You ask the participants to choose only one photo.
- Ask participants the write down the following as individuals:
- Why did you choose this photo?
- What does it mean for you?
- What do you think the photographer wanted to tell?
- Then pair participants to discuss with each other about their responses.
In that way, the participants will have an understanding about the reasons why they choose one photo over others, while making them learn about their perceptions, values and meaning orientations. Moreover, they will as well as try to understand what the photographer wanted to tell by the evaluating the photo itself.
In the end of the method, the facilitator debriefs the group about the process. Then explains the PhotoVoice Method and why we are using the PhotoVoice as a tool to promote inclusive photography and making the photography as a tool for change.
Diving into Photo Voice Method
During this process, you have to explain the reasons of using photo voice and the expectations from the participants in the two-day process. Then the participants are introduced the photovoice method its advantages, the usage within this project and 6 stages of photo voice.
They are informed that the first 5 stages of the photo voice is going to be implemented within this training activity and the last stage will be done in national exhibition after the implementation of visual storytelling workshops.
In the first stage, the participants are requested to choose a theme i.e. research question. In this process, we suggest you use post-its and ask participants to define one particular issue that they see at heart problematic. Then ask them to formulate that into a question.
The research question can be formulated by the participants concerning to the themes that are chosen. In our project, our main goal is to promote the inclusivity and inclusive societies though, the themes can vary with the cross-cutting issues such as gender equality, violence, peace and etc. Therefore, we give you some examples below concerning to the research question formulation.
Inclusion, Exclusion, Discrimination :
- How do you define the inclusion in your community?
- What do you think can be done to achieve an inclusive society in your country?
- How do the people are feeling about the discrimination towards themselves?
These questions are the guiding questions to lead the participants that might be coming from themselves with a deliberative discussion. Therefore, it is important to let go the process to ensure that the participants have full control of the themes and the questions that they would like to work on.
After the finalisation of this process, you do a short debriefing concerning to the overall process. During the debriefing you can use the following questions :
- How do you feel up to now?
- What do you think about the process of elaboration on the theme?
- Is there anything you would like to add to the process?
- Do you feel something is unclear or missing?
After the finalisation of the debriefing, you can close the session by explaining that, they will continue with the next step as “Taking Photos” to tackle with the artistic and aesthetic aspects of the photography.
Tips for Facilitators
“Say me why you are here” might be complicated to implement with participants who are unfamiliar to the non-formal education. You can choose different getting to know each other activities engaging the participants to get to know each other and increase its scope with asking fears and expectations of participants.
We kindly ask you to read the first two section of this handbook to familiarize yourself with the PhotoVoice methodology to tackle with the possible questions can come from the participants to ensure that you are prepared.
Let the participants discuss until it goes out of the scope that you have planned to do during the finding out the research question and the theme. The point is that they work on the issues that they value and they see as important rather than dictating what they should work on.
Additional Information and Readings
1) Sample Pictures that can be used : https://links.verdesur.org/sample-pictures
2) Slides which can be adopted to your own context : https://links.verdesur.org/slides-1st-day-photography
The slides are developed to be used within the consortium countries, though, anyone can download and adopt them by changing the context in their communities.
In addition to that, to increase the accessibility of the event, ensure that, the material is provided with easy-to-read way for the participants or their own country language. You can reach out the materials in the training resource pack in Spanish, Turkish, Serbian and Italian except than the English generic resources that are developed.
Readings
If you would like to get informed about the photo voice more deeper, you can use the following reading list to increase your knowledge and perception about the implementation and power of Photo Voice activities.
- Pienimäki, Mari (2021) Participatory photography supporting the social inclusion of migrant youth, Journal of Youth Studies, 24:9, 1179-1198
- Wang C, Burris MA. Photovoice: Concept, Methodology, and Use for Participatory Needs Assessment. Health Education & Behavior. 1997;24(3):369-387. doi:10.1177/109019819702400309
- Liebenberg, L. (2018). Thinking Critically About Photovoice: Achieving Empowerment and Social Change. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 17(1).
- Lorenz,L. ; Webster B.(2001), Doing Your Own PhotoVoice Project.
- https://www.brainline.org/sites/default/files/Photovoice_Facilitators_Guide.pdf
- Photovoice Hamilton - Manual and Resource Kit (2007) | https://www.naccho.org/uploads/downloadable-resources/Programs/Public-Health-Infrastructure/Photovoice-Manual.pdf